Are you looking for a delicious, indulgent dessert recipe? This gluten-free French butter cake is exactly that!
If you know me, you know that I rarely venture into the territory of box-mixes – I just like cooking from scratch so much!
But there was this one French Butter Cake recipe that mom found years and years ago, back in the day when all us kids still lived at home.
And it. was. good. The whole family fell head over heals for it.
The butter, the gooey filling, the cake bottom. There wasn’t a crumb left after we finished with it – not a hard feat when you’re a family of ten, but still.
We loved it!
Of course, the whole recipe was created around the use of a box of yellow cake mix.
The advantage to that of course is that cake mix makes it all very fast and easy.
The disadvantage is that it’s hard to find a gluten-free cake mix that you can use cup for cup in a recipe like that.
So, I was in Walmart last week, and bought a Pillsbury cake mix – hey, somebody’s gotta do the research 😉 plus, you can save on Pillsbury with Ibotta so it’s not such a splurge. If you’re not interested in buying a box mix, go ahead and make homemade gluten-free cake mix. It works like a charm too!
This cake is perfection on a plate. Every time we make it, it’s just so good.
While I’m usually a homemade cake mix fan, I have to say I loved how Pillsbury made it so easy to get the kids involved. “open it up and dump it in” is Garrett’s favorite kind of measuring method. 😉
It’s so fun how the kids want to be involved in everything we do. Even if it’s just holding a reflector so mommy can take pictures.
Although that may be because I promised him a bite afterward.
I like to think my kids will have the same kind of warm memories of helping mama bake in the kitchen, and the deliciousness of the fruit of our labors!
Gluten-free French Butter Cake
Tweaks you can make:
- Use a flavored cake mix for different gooey butter cake flavors. I love chocolate gooey butter cake (that recipe is from scratch btw). And strawberry is pretty awesome too!
- Use a slightly smaller pan for thicker layers. I love a thick, gooey layer, so I sometimes use my 8×11 inch baking pan instead of 9×13, and bake it for about 5 minutes longer.
- Add some fresh berry toppings! The relatively richness of this cake makes it a great pairing for the lighter feel and flavor of fresh berries. My favorites are strawberries, and blackberries.
- You can also make it the day before you need it. This cake is a champ for staying fresh overnight. Just make sure you cover it with a flour sack towel!
Gluten-Free French Butter Cake
A buttery cake crust, with a gooey cream cheese filling.
- Prep Time: 10 minutes
- Cook Time: 35 minutes
- Total Time: 45 minutes
- Yield: 12 servings 1x
- Category: dessert
- Method: oven
- Cuisine: American
- Diet: Gluten Free
Ingredients
- Bottom layer:
- 1 Pillsbury Gluten-Free yellow Cake Mix
- 1/2 cup butter, melted
- 2 eggs
- Top layer:
- 1, 8oz. block of cream cheese, softened
- 2 eggs
- 4 cups powdered sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350º
- Lightly grease a 9×13 inch baking dish and set aside.
- In a large bowl, mix together first three ingredients (cake mix, butter, and 2 eggs) until completely incorporated.
- In a second large bowl, combine remaining ingredients and beat until smooth.
- Press cake mix mixture into prepared baking dish.
- Pour cream cheese mixture on top, and spread evenly.
- Bake in center of the oven for 35-40 minutes, until cake no longer jiggles when moved (the toothpick test won’t work on this cake!)
- Remove from oven and allow to cool.
- Once cake is cool, cut into squares and serve.
- Store any leftovers in the refrigerator for up to a week.
- Enjoy!
Keywords: gluten-free french butter cake
Get Your Garden Cheat Sheets!
Want to know exactly when, where, and how to plant your vegetables? Sign up to get our FREE companion planting guide, and garden planting cheat sheet printable.
Elizabeth says
I’m so confused- how can this be gluten-free if it uses a boxed cake mix?? Is it a gluten-free cake mix? It doesn’t state that on the recipe list.
Elise says
Sorry about the confusion! I didn’t think to reiterate in the recipe card to use Pillsbury’s gluten-free cake mix since I’d stated that earlier in the post. I’m fixing it now though!
Coleen Marshall says
You call for a pan-and the picture shows a glass pan. Is that what I need to bake this cake in–or can I use a metal pan?
Elise says
I’ve used both. Just remember that a metal pan will brown slightly quicker than glass.
Barbie says
Is there a yummy fruit topping that would go well with this? Or is it better to leave as is?
Elise says
I think any kind of berries would work really well to help cut the richness of the cake. 🙂
Staci says
My mom suggested a small spoonful of pie filling on top of each piece! I’m going to use cherry, blueberry and strawberry!
Elise says
That’s a fabulous idea!
Mary says
Hello! I love this recipe and it is actually one of the only desserts my non gluten-free friends and family enjoy. I was just wondering if there is a way to make it less sweet. I assume it is the top layer. I was wondering if it would be okay to use less powdered sugar or would that throw the topping off.
Elise says
Glad you like it! 🙂 The topping may be slightly gooier if you use less sugar, but is that really a bad thing?
MamaSchick says
Really good! I loved how easy – and quick – this came together. I had most of the ingredients on hand. I added 1 teaspoon of almond extract with the vanilla, and might try some lemon zest next time. I’d love a little citrus kick.
This is defiantly going to be my “go to” for a quick and easy GF dessert.
*one older gal that ate it thought it was a little too sweet, I thought it was absolutely perfect. Not too sweet at all! To each her own I guess 🙂
Thanks for sharing!
Elise says
Thanks for sharing – Glad you liked it!
Claudia says
My young son made this for a baking competition with very little help from me. He won first prize! Everyone devoured it!
★★★★★
Elise says
Awesome! Tell him I said congratulations!
Ross says
Can a regular cake mix be used to replace gluten free mix?
ross says
I picked up a regular cake mix, can I make adjustments to this recipe and still use the cake mix?
Elise says
The gluten-free cake mix in this recipe is 17oz. As long as your traditional cake mix is equivalent to that, it should be fine. 🙂
Tina Wilson says
thanks so much for the recipe, I am making it tomorrow. My Mom and Grandma have to be gluten free and this will be a great treat for them.
Thanks
Zizi says
This is known as Gooey Butter Cake in St. Louis and is hugely popular. Local bakeries make all kinds of flavors. I grew up on this. Ive never heard it called French. St. Louis was founded by the French, so maybe someone wanted to make it sound fancy.
★★★★★
Elise says
Yeah, my mom used a recipe that called it “French Butter Cake” Since then, I’ve mostly heard it called “Gooey Butter Cake”, but I’m a stickler for family nostalgia I guess. 😛
Karen says
This was so delicious !!! Made it for a gluten free friend and she said never tasted a dessert so yummy !
Elise says
So glad you liked it!
Melissa F. says
You’ve nailed this recipe! Thank you so much. I’m a Philadelphia native and butter cake is practically a food group all its own. My family had one for every holiday when I was growing up. I’m in a women’s group at our church and this week our topic is to bring or make a food that we have a memory of … I went online searching for a gluten-free butter cake, found this, and made it tonight. Absolute perfection. Thank you, thank you, thank you for bringing part of my childhood back to me this evening!
★★★★★
Wbhurt says
Yellow cake mix was not available, but they did have gluten free pilsbury funfetti mix. So i used that and it turned out great and was slightly festive. After reading some comments about the sweetness i decided to add the zest of one lemon and 1/8 tspn salt to the topping. Everybody loved it. Great recipe!
★★★★★
Courtney says
Yummy! I also couldn’t find the yellow cake mix so I used the funfetti mix and sifted the sprinkles out. Very tasty and easy!
★★★★★
Molly says
Do you add 2 eggs o the batter and 2 to the cream cheese mix?
Elise says
Yes, two eggs in each layer.
Cheryl K says
There is no recipe showing up here. Where is it listed?
sandi says
OMGOMG, I just spent 1 hour looking for the recipe. where is it? I am so frustrated and close to tears. this would be perfect for my team member for her birthday.
Elise says
Hi Sandi, Some people seem to be having trouble seeing the recipes when viewing on an iPad. We’re still trying to figure out what the bug is. But in the meantime, here’s the recipe: https://www.frugalfarmwife.com/article/gluten-free-french-butter-cake-2/cookbook-print/7548/
Lindsey says
I got so many compliments on this cake!! Thank you! Question though, your directions said to bake for 35-40 minutes until the middle no longer jiggles. For me, the middle didn’t stop juggling until 50 minutes…The middle of the cake was still delicious but the edges were as hard as a rock…Did I bake it too long and a bit of jiggle is ok?
★★★★★
Elise says
Hmm, It may be that your oven runs hotter than mine, so the edges are getting overdone before the middle does. So, you could try lowering the oven temp, or let the middle be a bit jiggly and see how it ends up once it’s cooled.
Pam Neumann says
HAS anyone made this at high altitude?
Are their adjustments on the box?
Roni says
I have made this at high altitude 6000 ft without any adjustments and it worked out beautifully.
Sara says
I made this cake for a bridal shower that I hosted this last weekend- and it was by far the most commented-on dish at the party and everyone wanted me to send them the recipe! No one could believe that it was gluten-free either. I used King Arthur GF Yellow Cake Mix instead of Pillsbury (because that is what was sold at my grocery store)- the KA cake mix was 22 oz- so I just measured out 17 oz of it, to match the amount of mix in the recipe. It also took nearly 45 minutes to bake so that the interior wasn’t “jiggly” but the exterior was not overdone at all. Thank you so much for posting this! Sooooo delicious!
Lorri says
Loved this cake! It is a keeper!
★★★★★
Brenda potts says
Can’t wait to try this for my grandaughter. She needs gluenten free and she is also diabetic. What can I do to make this with less sugar.
She had been diabetic since she was 2, now 19 and just found out she also has celiac also.
Whole new cooking experience for us.
Elise says
I don’t know that this particular recipe is suitable for reducing sugar. I would try googling diabetic or keto recipes for that.
Melanie Thompson says
Elise! Imagine my surprise to be scrolling thru Pinterest’s suggestions for me and clicking on this recipe and seeing you guys! First time to randomly find a person that I know IRL thru Pinterest. So neat! 🙂 this recipe sounds delicious, especially after reading all the comments! Jack and Grace are both sensitive to egg though, so i will be wondering about trying it with an egg substitute. We shall see! Hope you guys are doing well.
Elise says
Hi Melanie, Great to hear from you!
I haven’t tried an egg substitute in this recipe, so I can’t really say. Sorry!
Shannon says
Made this recipe and it is better the second day after chilling in the refrigerator overnight! If you can wait that long. Delicious!!!
★★★★★
Erica says
I had great success with this recipe today. I could only find Bobs Red Mill gf vanilla cake mix (the kind in the bag) and I was a little unsure since the directions on the Bobs bag say to also add 1/2 cup of water with the butter. The batter looked too dry and thick so I did end up adding around 1/4 cup of water. I think if I’d added the whole amount, that would have been fine too. Anyway, everything else I followed to a T and it was delicious! Gf and non-gf partakers alike enjoyed it immensely 🙂
★★★★★
Sandy says
Just received a large box of chocolate Bobs Redmill GF cake mix would that work in this recipe?
Elise says
Yep. You could make a Chocolate version!
Mary says
Tried it for a birthday for my husband, sweet tooth, turns out it is really yummy and not as surgery as I expected it to be. Thanks for a new way to say Happy B-Day in my family.
Cindy says
is it the 15 or 17 oz size box of Pillsbury mix?
Shari K says
17 oz. I used a 15 oz Betty Crocker mix and added 6 Tbs of GF Bisquick to make up the difference
Jen says
This recipe is so delicious! I have made it several times and everyone always loves it! Thank you!
★★★★★
Nancy says
Easy to make. Delicious! Husband loved it.
★★★★★
Lynda says
Has anyone tried this as cupcakes? We love this recipe but need something for a Grab and go type buffet at school.
★★★★★
Dee says
I made this for a wedding shower, the mother of the bride is gluten free. I made a “traditional” and this one. To be honest everyone at the party (which included my teen sons and hers) liked the gluten free version better. I also used the Pilsbury cake mix. The bride tried it (she is a St. Louis native) and said she thought it had a better texture than the other one as well.
Diane says
Not sure what I did wrong but top had a dry, “crusty” look and the cake did not jiggle at 35 minutes so I took it out. When I went to cut it after cooling, it was not done.
Jessica says
Mine too! And it’s taking over an hour to cook!
Mine also “spilled” over! So, I have no idea what I did wrong, but still edible and very good!
Jennilyn says
Do you think I could make this dairy free also?
Lori M McArthur says
You could make this dairy free by using a substitute butter such as melt or earth balance. Then use a substitute for cream cheese, Kite Hill makes the best one. I am going to try this as I am both gf and do.
Lori M McArthur says
Dairy free not DO.
Teresa says
Well I made it sugar free, so not exactly how it was written. I used a yellow sugar free cake mix from Pillsbury. I thought it was too sweet and the cake part was dry around the edges. I’m going to have to try a different powdered sugar substitute, or use less. I used Monkfruit powdered sugar, which requires you to use 1/2 the amount of regular powdered sugar. I still found it too sweet. We topped it with vanilla bean ice cream which really helped to cut the sweetness. My husband loved it though. Probably would be great with fresh berries on top. I’ll try it again, but using less sweetener.
★★★
Pam says
This sounds like the St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake. Is it?
Claudine says
Made this tonight and everyone loved it. We are new into gluten free bc our daughter has a sensitivity we just found. Wanted to serve with strawberries but the kids had already eaten them. This was so very good!!!
★★★★★
Christina says
This was way to sweet for me. I would cut the icing sugar in half.
★★★
Jessica says
Made a rookie mistake and cut into this before it was fully cool. Runny mess! Make sure to let it cool, it’s not a suggestion. 😂