| | | |

Fall Spice Goat Milk Soap Recipe


Looking to upgrade your soap stash for fall? This Fall Spice Goat Milk Soap Recipe is perfect!

Image shows a stack of home made soap, with copy that reads "Fall Spice Goat Milk Soap"

I don’t know about you, but I’m always a little disappointed when I find a beautiful looking soap recipe on Pinterest, click over, and it starts with “go to Hobby Lobby and buy melt and pour soap base”.

Honey, I’m not looking at homemade soap recipes so I can go buy a perfectly good block of soap and melt it down.

I don’t have time to prettify perfectly functional soap.

I make my own soap so I can control what’s in it. The oils and essential oil it’s made of, and the liquid that dissolved the lye, and how they all affect my skin.

I’ll never forget my first experience with homemade soap – while most soap dries my skin out, and I immediately reach of the lotion bottle after washing my hands, the homemade soap didn’t.

I later found out that part of this homemade soap’s moisturizing power came from the goat milk in it, another part came from being super fatted – that is, there was slightly more fat in the soap than the lye could saponify, and the rest was because homemade soap isn’t separated from the glycerin it produces.

Image shows ingredients for the soap being weighed on a digital scale

See, most cheap commercial soap is actually a detergent – all the glycerin has been removed for other purposes, and you’re left only with the harsh cleaning component.

That’s why I make homemade soap, and it’s probably why I’m not very good at making it pretty.

for the most part, I don’t bother with making photogenic soap – no ultramarine colors or intricate layers and swirls. Maybe someday, but for now, that kind of thing isn’t my jam.

I do like to add botanicals – lavender buds if I’m making lavender soap, oatmeal, obviously for oatmeal bars, dried orange peel for orange soap, and coffee grounds for coffee scrub soap – that kind of thing.

Photo shows the fall spice soap mixture in molds

But no, I’m not really in the business of making pretty soap.

I am however in the business of making soap that smells amazing, and fall scents are some of the best.

Making amazing smelling soap is as simple as having a few quality essential oils. For the most part, I use Young Living essential oils exclusively, however, in applications where expensive oils are getting saponified, I sometimes also use Now brand essential oils.

I realize there is controversy surrounding which essential oils are really the real deal, and which ones are junk.

I know for sure that Young Living is the only company that grows their own and can guarantee purity, but I also know that Now brand is very careful about sourcing quality oils as well, so while I wouldn’t put them directly on my skin, or for sure use them internally, I’m okay with using them in soap making.

Image shows several bars of homemade fall spice soap sitting on a white surface

So anyhoo… This fall spice goat milk soap recipe – I couldn’t call it pumpkin pie, or pumpkin spice soap, because it doesn’t have any actual pumpkin in it.

What it has is all the spices you would find in a pumpkin pie.

All the warm, spice scents of fall.

When making soap, always do it in a well ventilated place – windows open or on a porch is great.

Always wear gloves, and goggles in case of splashes – lye can give you serious burns!

Fall Spice Goat Milk Soap Recipe


  • 2.29 oz/65 grams. lye
  • 5.28 oz/150 grams goat milk
  • 2 oz/56 grams avocado oil
  • 6 oz/170 grams coconut oil
  • 4 oz/114 grams soybean oil
  • 1 milliliter each cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, and ginger essential oil
  • 1 Tablespoon pumpkin pie spice (optional)


  1. Freeze goat milk until icy, but not solid. The colder it is, the lighter the color of your finished soap will be
  2. Remove goat milk from freezer and add lye
  3. Stir until lye is dissolved and set aside in a safe place away from children
  4. Combine oils in a sauce pan and heat to 100º Fahrenheit (or use a glass bowl and the microwave)
  5. Transfer to a large glass bowl
  6. Stir in lye mixture being careful not to splash
  7. Continue stirring until soap reaches a trace. This process is best done with a stick/immersion blender to speed the process up.
  8. When soap is at a trace, stir in essential oils and pumpkin pie spice
  9. Fill molds with soap mixture (This recipe will fill all six cavities in this mold)
  10. Set soap in a place where it won’t be disturbed for several hours or a few days until it has hardened
  11. Remove soap from molds once hard, and let cure for three weeks before using.

Get Your Garden Cheat Sheets!

Want to know exactly when, where, and how to plant your vegetables? Sign up to get our FREE companion planting guide, and garden planting cheat sheet printable.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit

Similar Posts


  1. Thank
    you for these recipes! I’m new to goats and really excited to try making soap! I have 2 questions for you….. saw in one of your recipes you no longer use Soybean oil. What did you substitute with?
    My milk is frozen in bags should I thaw then weigh?

  2. Hi Elise!
    I love your goats milk soap recipes! In this one, would it be beneficial to add a teaspoon of ground cinnamon to the soap instead of the cinnamon es? Also, why not add a combination of ground mulling spices including anise, cloves, allspice and grated ground orange peel? I’m wondering if these would add any frangrance.

    1. The oils are much more potent for fragrance. You can add powdered spices, and you may get a little bit of fragrance from them, but you might want to think of them more as exfoliants than fragrance.

  3. Hi Elise! I love your soap recipes! I’ve never had one fail, but to was a different story. 😢 After putting the essential oils in and beating some more till they were mixed, the soap set up quickly and began to separate. A huge mess! What May have happened?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *